Independent Australian and global macro analysis

Sunday, November 3, 2019

Australian retail sales in September +0.2%; Q3 volumes -0.1%

Australian retail spending disappointed expectations in September with little sign that recent stimulus measures have gained traction with consumers, indicating that weak confidence could be weighing. Over the September quarter, real retail sales contracted by 0.1% in a much weak-than-expected result. 

Retail Sales — September | By the numbers
  • Retail turnover increased by 0.2% in September to $A27.59bn to disappoint the market median forecast of 0.4% (prior: 0.4%). 
  • Turnover growth in annual terms was unchanged at 2.5% after allowing for a downward revision from 2.6% in the previous month. In trend terms, turnover lifted by 0.2% in September and 2.4% over the year.   

  • Retail volumes (nominal spending adjusted for price changes) fell by 0.1% in Q3, which was well below the 0.3% gain expected by markets and reversed a 0.1% increase in Q2.  
  • Annual volume growth swung from +0.2% to -0.2% and is at its weakest pace in 28 years.   


Retail Sales — September | The details

Retail spending in nominal terms lifted by 0.2% in September to $27.59bn (+2.5%Y/Y), with gains coming from food (+0.1%), 'other' (+0.8%) and cafes and restaurants (+0.6%). Categories that declined in the month were; clothing and footwear (-0.5%) and department stores (-0.2%), while household goods were flat. Sales ex-food lifted by 0.2% in September and 2.1% for the year. In Q3, turnover increased by 0.6% with the details being; food +0.6%, household goods +0.8%, clothing and footwear +1.4%, department stores +0.1%, other +0.7% and cafes and restaurants -0.3%. Excluding food, turnover lifted by 0.5% in Q3.   


Retail prices increased by 0.6% in the September quarter and was slightly above the 0.5% rise in Q2. Referencing the pass-through impact from a weaker Australian dollar, clothing and footwear prices lifted by 1.1% in Q3 to outpace rises from food (+0.7%), department stores (+0.2%), other (+0.4%) and cafes and restaurants (+0.8%). The main influence on prices over the past year has been from food, likely due to drought-related impacts.  


Adjusting nominal sales for these price changes, total volumes fell by 0.1% over the quarter. The details were; food 0.0%, household goods +0.9%, clothing and footwear +0.3%, department stores -0.1%, other +0.3% and cafes and restaurants -1.0%. Volumes ex-food were down by 0.1% in Q3 highlighting weakness in discretionary-related demand.  


The 4-quarter profile for retail volumes is; -0.1% (Q4 2018), -0.1% (Q1 2019), +0.1% (Q2 2019) and -0.1% (Q3 2019). As a result, the annual pace has fallen to -0.2% — its weakest since Q2 1991. Weighing on this has been price increases over the past 4 quarters of 0.8% (Q4 2018), 0.7% (Q1 2019), 0.5% (Q2 2019) and 0.6% (Q3 2019).   


Retail spending was soft across the major states of New South Wales and Victoria in September, which combined account for nearly 60% of national turnover. For the month, New South Wales posted a modest 0.3% rise as spending stalled in Victoria. In Q3, spending lagged the national increase (0.6%) for both states; New South Wales +0.4% and Victoria +0.5%. Over the past year, turnover in Victoria at 2.6% has run at twice the pace of that in New South Wales at 1.3% and is also slightly above the national pace (+2.5%). 


The details for the remaining states in September were generally positive; Queensland -0.1%, South Australia +0.2%, Western Australia +0.7% and Tasmania +1.0%. Standouts in Q3 were Western Australia (+1.6%) and Tasmania (+1.3%), with both Queensland (+0.4%) and South Australia (0.0%) soft. In annual terms, Queensland is leading the nation* (+4.2%) followed by Western Australia (+3.5%), while Tasmania is in line with the national pace but is notably weaker in South Australia (+1.7%). *Note ACT is running at a 4.3% annual pace but only accounts for a little under 2% of national turnover compared to 20% for Queensland. 


Retail Sales — September | Insights

This was a weak and disappointing update on retail sales with few indications that recent stimulus from RBA rate cuts and federal government tax relief have gained traction with consumers. One possible explanation is that with consumer sentiment according to Westpac Melbourne Institute's Index having weakened sharply since mid-year to currently sit well in pessimistic territory, consumers are looking to save more of this cash flow benefit. Overall, weak wages growth remains a strong headwind for retail sales and indications are that household consumption growth will slow further in Q3's National Accounts.